madeleone: (Default)
madeleone ([personal profile] madeleone) wrote2011-05-23 07:56 pm
Entry tags:

I love reviews but....

I have to wonder what is in some people's heads...

 

Is very confused by reviewer who reads a story which is clearly labeled Hermione G. & Severus S. then leaves comments such as:

 

I'm not impressed this was Snape - I honestly was expecting Remus

????Why on earth would you expect Remus when it's HG/SS???

 

I might just run to the bathroom to throw up at the thought of Severus naked

????Then why the hell are you reading HG/SS????

 

I'm still weirded out by his presence in this story, by the by.

????Why would you be weirded out... it's a HG/SS story????

 

Then on the last chapter she says:

Very nice story, I quite enjoyed it.

 

But then feels compelled to add:

You should be impressed that I stayed on to finish it despite the whole thing being about Snape and Hermione - I've never been a fan of Snape

AAARRRRRGGGHHHH!!!!

 

I have only posted snippets of her comments here, but upon reading some of the wording of her comments, I am thinking that she is very young.

But still, if you don't like Snape and don't want to imagine him and Hermione together then for gods sake don't read stories labeled HG/SS!

[identity profile] scifichick774.livejournal.com 2011-05-24 01:24 am (UTC)(link)
It's very confusing. I can understand reading a pairing that you might not otherwise, just because you've heard good things about the author or the premise looks appealing. But to read when you actively dislike a certain character, one that is going to be the lead in that story, seems absolutely ridiculous.